Academic Paper

Change Now, Architecture Later

Author: Matthew Crabbe (TU Berlin)

  • Change Now, Architecture Later

    Academic Paper

    Change Now, Architecture Later

    Author:

Abstract

This is an accepted article with a DOI pre-assigned that is not yet published.

Abstract:

In my dissertation “Change Now, Architecture Later!” I look to understand why so many architecture graduates are leaving university with serious doubts about becoming architects. To understand this dynamic from different perspectives, I combined traditional qualitative methods, such as biographical interviews, with practice-based visual ethnographic methods, such as portrait photography and photo elicitation. The thesis paints an ominous picture of a profession failing to convince graduates of its capacity for transformation. My findings make clear that this is not just a question of content or ecological agenda but rather a manifest scepticism about the established identities, structures and working conditions of the architecture profession. Ultimately raising the question of whether a more progressive, transformative and ecological architecture practice can be made viable for most practitioners in the current system without resorting to the self-sacrifice and unfair working conditions that my research is so critical of.


Navigating the practice gap is widely accepted as a necessary step toward becoming an architect. An architecture degree does not teach you everything you need to be an architect—or not be an architect, for that matter—and the adjustment period for graduates after university can often be extremely challenging as the scale and multitude of practice gaps become apparent. For many, early career experiences and decisions are entangled with building a stable narrative of the self that can integrate their transformative personal aspirations with the contradictions of navigating an increasingly diverse and often disillusioning professional landscape. The investigation finds that while the emergence of ecology as a new kind of class struggle (Latour & Schultz, 2022) is undoubtedly a central pillar of many graduates’ life-politics, an increasingly generational gap in values and understanding concerning personal and collective well-being is becoming a wedge issue in many workplaces and significantly widening the practice-gap. In the context of the current shortage of specialised workers, practice often blames universities for not providing “practice-ready” graduates, but considering the doubts graduates have about the structures of the profession, who is to say that they will aspire to become professional architects at all?


While historically, professions or work acted as strong bastions of identification in our lives, in today’s climate of “constant crisis,” the security of a solid identity in a stable career with societal recognition is becoming ever less the norm for graduates. With digitalisation already fundamentally transforming how expertise is organised and distributed in society (Susskind & Susskind, 2022), the above question can be understood in more existential terms: for how long will there be a “stable” architecture profession for them to aspire to? Answering this question means accepting that the working lives of many graduates will be defined by constant change as they engage with new forms of practice in which they can pursue their transformative agendas on the borders of disciplines. These changing perspectives give rise to a situative professionality (Ziemer, 2013) that differs greatly from the controlled and regulated professional identity required for accreditation as an architect. Indeed, my research shows that these dynamics can foster great optimism for architecture graduates, whose studies provide them with transferable skills that enable them to succeed in new professions or even totally unrelated sectors (Barosio et al., 2024). And so the question emerges - with so much need for change, why so much focus on the architecture?

Keywords: architectural education, professional identity, practice-gap, controversies, situative professionality

Accepted on
20 Oct 2026